A reclaimed barn beam gives you wood that has already done most of its drying and checking, plus decades of marks you can't fake. You take it as found: its size, its length, its nail holes and sometimes its bugs. A new-sawn beam is cut to the size, length and species you want, with clean, sound wood, but it's still drying and will check more after it goes up. Choose reclaimed for the history and the stability. Choose new-sawn for the fit and the control.
What you get with a reclaimed beam
Dry wood. A beam that's spent decades in a barn has had time to dry close to the air around it. It has already shrunk and checked, so it moves less once it's inside. That's the main practical advantage.
History you can see. Mortises where braces joined, peg holes, notches, adze or broadaxe marks on hand-hewn beams, saw marks from an old mill, nail holes, a gray weathered surface. Each beam is unique, and some buyers want to know which barn it came from.
The size it was. Barn timbers were sized for the barn, not your fireplace. You find a beam that's close and cut it to length. It may be out of square, slightly bowed or twisted, and its faces may not be flat enough to sit tight to a wall.
What to watch for with reclaimed
- Metal. Old beams hide nails, spikes, bolts and broken-off hardware, sometimes painted or rusted over. Anyone cutting or planing the beam needs to find it first.
- Insects. Small round holes and tunnels are common. Old holes are fine. Fresh, flour-like dust under the holes, or dust that comes back after you clean it, means insects are still active. Ask whether the beam has been treated, and don't bring an active one into the house.
- Rot. Beams from a wet sill or near a roof leak can be soft inside. Push an awl into suspect spots, especially on the ends and the bottom face.
- Paint and contaminants. Barn beams are usually bare, but one that was painted may carry old lead paint. Test painted surfaces before sanding. Beams from livestock barns can need a good cleaning.
- Species. Old Midwest barns used whatever grew nearby, often oak but sometimes a mix, and an old gray surface hides the wood. A fresh cut on an end shows what you have.
- Price. Good reclaimed beams are usually sold at a premium, since they're limited and take work to salvage and clean.
Questions to ask a reclaimed beam seller
- Where did it come from? A barn, a mill building, a house? A seller who knows the source usually knows the species too.
- What species is it? Ask to see a fresh cut on an end.
- Has it been checked for metal? Ask how, and whether anything was removed.
- Has it been treated for insects? And is there any fresh dust from active holes?
- Has it been cleaned? Pressure-washed, brushed or left as found.
- What are its real dimensions? Measure both ends and the middle; old beams vary along their length.
- How has it been stored? Indoors and dry, or outside in a pile?
What you get with a new-sawn beam
Your size and length. The beam is cut to the cross-section and length your fireplace needs, square and straight.
Your species. You pick the wood, and you know what you're getting.
Clean wood. Fresh faces, without old nail holes, insect tunnels or rot.
The trade-off: moisture. A new beam has had months, or at most a few years, to dry, not decades. It will keep drying, shrinking and checking after it goes up, especially over a fire. Those checks are usually cosmetic, but you'll see more of them than on a reclaimed beam. Our guide Will a solid wood mantel crack? explains how to keep them small.
Side by side
| Reclaimed barn beam | New-sawn beam | |
|---|---|---|
| Dryness | Close to dry already | Green or air-dried; keeps drying |
| New checks after hanging | Few | More, mostly cosmetic |
| Size and length | As found, cut to length | Cut to your size and length |
| Straight and square | Often not | Yes |
| Species | Often oak; can be unknown | Your choice |
| Surface | Patina, mortises, hewn marks | Fresh saw marks |
| Hidden metal and insects | Possible; check | Unlikely |
| Price | Usually higher | Usually lower |
Can a new beam look old?
Partly. A new beam can be wire-brushed to raise the grain, given a hand-hewn texture, or left rough-sawn so the saw marks show. A stain or an oxidizing wash can gray or darken it. What a new beam can't fake well is decades of weathering, joinery cut by a timber framer, or real wear.
On the other hand, a new beam can be cut from a tree with a story of its own: a walnut from a family farm or an oak from your own yard. Our guide on making a mantel from your own tree explains how.
Which to choose
Go reclaimed if you want history and character, you need a beam that won't move much right away, and you can work with the sizes available.
Go new-sawn if you need an exact size or a long length, want a specific species or a clean, square beam, or want to avoid hidden metal and insects.
We cut new beams to order from Missouri logs, and each one comes with its drying history: fresh-sawn or how many months it has air-dried.
For sizes and weights, see mantel beams.
Get a Mantel Quote
Describe the beam you're picturing, size and surface, and we'll price a new-sawn one cut to fit.