The best wood for a fireplace mantel is the one that suits your room and that your wall can carry. Black walnut gives the richest color, white oak a favorite modern look, red oak bold grain at a lower price, and eastern red cedar a rustic look at about two-thirds the weight of white oak. Sycamore, ash and elm are less common choices that are worth a look if you want something different.
Below, each wood is compared for mantel use, by how it looks on the wall, what a beam weighs, how much it moves as it dries and how it takes a finish.
Comparison table
| Wood | Color | Weight, lb per cu ft | 6x8 beam, lb per ft | Shrinkage, green to oven-dry | Stain | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Black walnut | Dark brown, pale sapwood | 38 | 13 | 12.8% | Rarely needed | Highest |
| White oak | Light tan to brown | 48 | 16 | 16.3% | Takes stain evenly; can be fumed | High |
| Northern red oak | Warm tan, rosy tone | 44 | 15 | 13.7% | Takes stain well | Middle |
| Eastern red cedar | Red heart, cream sapwood, knotty | 33 | 11 | 7.8% | Usually left natural | Lowest |
| Sycamore | Pale tan, fine fleck | 34 | 11 | 14.1% | Can blotch | Middle |
| White ash | Pale cream to light brown | 42 | 14 | 13.3% | Takes stain well | Middle |
| American elm | Light brown, wild grain | 35 | 12 | 14.6% | Takes stain fairly well | Low to middle |
How to read it:
- Weight is at 12% moisture content, worked out from the specific gravity figures in the USDA Forest Products Laboratory Wood Handbook, chapter 5. The 6x8 column is pounds per foot of beam length; multiply by the length in feet.
- Shrinkage is the Wood Handbook's average volumetric shrinkage from green to oven-dry (chapter 4). A mantel never dries that far, so read it as a comparison: a higher number means a wood that moves and checks more as it dries.
- Price is relative, from cheapest to dearest, not a dollar figure. See mantel prices for national ranges.
Black walnut
Walnut is the wood people picture when they say "nice mantel." The heartwood is a deep chocolate brown, sometimes with purple or gray streaks, and the sapwood along the outside of the tree is pale cream. On a live edge mantel, that pale band along the front edge is the whole effect. On a squared beam, you can choose a piece that's all dark heart, or one with a strip of sapwood on a corner.
Walnut is moderately heavy and moves less than oak, so it checks less as it dries. It needs no stain. A clear oil or a matte clear finish deepens the brown, and walnut lightens slightly toward a warmer brown over the years.
Missouri grows a lot of walnut, but large, clear walnut beams are still the priciest mantels in any shop.
White oak
White oak is the current design favorite: light tan, straight-grained, and quiet enough to suit a modern room or a farmhouse. Cut on the quarter, it shows silvery ray fleck across the face.
It's also the heaviest wood here, at about 16 pounds per foot for a 6x8, and the one that shrinks most as it dries. That makes checking the main risk with a white oak beam. A white oak mantel that went up green will open checks over the first winter or two of fires.
White oak takes light stains evenly, and it reacts with ammonia fumes, which darken it without a stain. Many people leave it natural with a clear matte finish.
Red oak
Red oak usually costs less than white oak or walnut, which makes it the value pick among the classic mantel woods. Its color is a warm tan with a pink tint, and the grain is bold and open, with long cathedral arches on the flat-sawn face.
It's heavy, about 15 pounds per foot for a 6x8 of northern red oak, and moves a little less than white oak. Its open pores soak up stain evenly, so red oak is a good pick if you want a mantel stained to match floors or trim. Left natural, it ambers slightly over time.
Eastern red cedar
Eastern red cedar grows on fence rows and old fields across Missouri. Its heartwood is red to purple-red, the sapwood is cream, and there are knots almost everywhere. The look is rustic and bright, and it smells of cedar when it's freshly cut.
Cedar is the lightest wood in the table, about 11 pounds per foot for a 6x8, and it shrinks least as it dries, so it's the easiest beam to mount and the least likely to check badly. The trade-offs: it's soft, so it dents, and the red fades toward brown without a finish that blocks UV light. Stain hides what makes cedar attractive, so it's usually left natural. Trees large enough for a big beam are less common than in the hardwoods, so cedar beams tend to be smaller.
Sycamore, ash and elm
Sycamore is creamy white to light tan. Cut on the quarter, it shows a dense, freckled ray pattern sometimes called lacewood. It shrinks a fair amount and is prone to warping, so it needs to be dry before it goes over a fireplace. It's an uncommon look that suits a light, Scandinavian-style room.
White ash looks like a paler oak, with strong grain and a creamy color. It's moderately heavy and takes stain well. Emerald ash borer has killed many of Missouri's ash trees, so ash beams sometimes come from trees that were taken down because they were dying.
American elm has wild, interlocked grain that looks lively on a beam but can twist as it dries. It's light brown and less common as a mantel, which is part of its appeal.
Stain or natural
Most solid wood mantels look best natural, with a clear finish that brings out the color the wood already has. A few rules of thumb:
- Leave natural: walnut, cherry and cedar. Stain dulls their color, and walnut is already dark.
- Stain if you need to match: red oak, white oak and ash take stain evenly because of their open grain.
- Test first: sycamore, maple and cherry can blotch, absorbing stain unevenly. Use a pre-stain conditioner and test on the back or an end.
- Rough-sawn beams soak up more stain than smooth ones, so the same stain looks darker on a rough face.
Whatever you use, test on the back or the underside first, and finish all sides so the beam takes up and loses moisture evenly. Our guide on finishing a rough-sawn mantel goes step by step.
Weight decides more than looks. If your wall is drywall over studs, or you want a long floating mantel, a lighter wood or a box beam may suit you better than solid white oak. See mantel beams for weights at every common size.
Get a Mantel Quote
Tell us the wood you like, the size and a photo of the fireplace, and we'll quote a mantel in that species, or suggest one that fits your wall better.