Choose a solid beam if you want a real timber, with end grain on the ends, the heft of one piece of wood and the option of a live edge, and your wall can carry it. Choose a box beam if the wall can't take the weight, you want a very large mantel, or you want something that won't open checks over a hot fireplace. From across the room, a well-made box beam looks like a solid one. Up close, the ends and corners tell them apart.
Here's how they compare on weight, cost, looks and installation.
What each one is
A solid beam is one piece of wood sawn from a log, usually from the center of the tree. It's as heavy as its size and species make it, and it keeps drying after it goes up.
A box beam is built from boards, typically three: a front, a top and a bottom, joined at the corners with miters or rabbets and glued. The back is open, and it slides over a wood cleat fixed to the wall. The ends are closed with caps, either a mitered piece of the same board or a block cut to look like end grain. Some people call it a hollow or faux beam. Don't confuse it with the big-box "faux" mantels made from foam or composite; a box beam made from real hardwood boards is solid wood on every face you see.
Weight
This is the big difference. Take a 6x8 black walnut mantel, 6 feet long, at 12% moisture content, using the USDA Forest Products Laboratory's density figure for walnut, about 38.5 pounds per cubic foot:
| Wood in the cross-section | Weight per foot | 6-foot mantel | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solid 6x8 | 48 sq in | about 12.8 lb | about 77 lb |
| Box, 1-inch boards | 20 sq in | about 5.3 lb | about 32 lb |
| Box, ¾-inch boards | about 15.4 sq in | about 4.1 lb | about 25 lb |
The box figures count a 6-inch-tall front and top and bottom boards 8 inches deep, with the top and bottom butting against the front. A 1-inch box comes in at about 40% of the solid beam's weight, and a ¾-inch box at about a third.
That's the difference between needing two strong helpers and rods set into framing or masonry, and one person lifting it onto a cleat screwed into studs.
Cost
A solid beam is priced mostly by its wood: a 6x8 holds 4 board feet in every foot of length. A 1-inch box of the same size uses about 1.7 board feet per foot, less than half the wood. But a box takes more labor: milling three boards flat and true, cutting long miters, gluing up, and fitting end caps.
So the comparison depends on the wood. In walnut, the most expensive mantel wood, the wood you save goes a long way toward covering the labor. In cedar or red oak, the wood costs little enough that the extra labor usually tips the balance toward solid. For very large mantels, like a 10x12, a box is usually the only practical option at all, because a solid beam that size is hard to find and very heavy.
For a solid beam, the national ranges (not our prices) are on our pricing page, with a table by length.
Look up close
Ends. A solid beam shows its growth rings and any end checks. A box beam's end is a cap. A careful maker cuts the cap from end grain or matches it to the boards, but it doesn't look like the end of a timber to someone who looks closely. If the ends of your mantel will be seen, say on a mantel that stops short of a side wall, this matters.
Corners. On a box, there's a glue line along the two front corners. Tight miters are hard to spot from a few feet away, especially on rough-sawn wood. Rabbeted corners show a strip of end grain.
Texture. Both can be rough-sawn, wire-brushed or smooth. A box beam made from rough-sawn boards with the saw marks running the same direction on all three faces looks very convincing.
Checks and movement. A solid beam will check as it dries; in many rooms that's part of its appeal. A box beam made from dry 1-inch boards barely moves, so it stays crisp. If you want the look of a weathered timber, a solid beam does it naturally.
Live edge. Only a solid piece can have a natural edge.
Installation
A box beam hangs on a cleat: a length of wood, sized to fit inside the box, screwed into studs or anchored to masonry. The box slides over it and is screwed through the top or bottom where the screws won't show. It's the easiest mantel to hang on a framed wall.
A solid beam needs steel rods, a hidden bracket or corbels, fixed to framing or solid masonry, rated for the beam's weight. Our mounting guide and brick guide cover it.
Fire clearances don't care whether the mantel is hollow. The 12-inch masonry rule and any gas or prefab manual apply to a box just as they do to a beam. A box beam is just as combustible as a solid one.
Which one to choose
Solid beam if:
- You want end grain, real heft and natural checking.
- The wall is solid masonry, or framed with studs where you need them.
- You want a live edge, or a reclaimed or hewn look.
Box beam if:
- The wall is a veneer or framing you can't easily reinforce.
- You want a big mantel, 10 inches or more, without the weight.
- You want a crisp, stable look over a fireplace that gets used hard.
Not sure? Send a photo of your wall and tell us what's behind it. Our floating mantels page compares the two for the no-visible-support look.
Get a Mantel Quote
Tell us the size you want and what your wall is made of, and we'll quote the mantel that suits it.